Buffalo Games Collectors & Hobbyists Puzzles

Shop by Category

Toys & Hobbies
- Puzzles
- Contemporary Puzzles
- Vintage Puzzles

1,444 Results

LOT OF 4 - RAVENSBURGER - 500 PC PIECES - PREMIUM JIGSAW PUZZLES - NEW & USED
$45.00
or Best Offer
$13.85 shipping
+^W &*J VV ] SR 99 wW.3?!|/ $S p o n s o r e d
LOT / 9 - BUFFALO PUZZLES - 300 / 500 / 750 PC PIECES - ANIMALS - CASTLES - DOGS
$65.00
or Best Offer
$17.85 shipping
6+C ^UV &* ]LK w.?!0|M / $S p o n s o r e d
Houston Astroworld Jigsaw Puzzle BUFFALO GAMES Vtg 1988 City Character Puzzle
$24.99
$7.67 shipping
+^ &1B *XY ] w. ?!5|/2 9V$ S p o n s o r e d
Devil’s Dilemma World's Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Buffalo Games 1987 Complete
$21.99
or Best Offer
$12.30 shipping
+^5Y &B*4 W J] wW.?D!| / $S p o n s o r e d
Vintage 1989 The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle Of All Time Two Sided 512pcs New
$10.77
or Best Offer
$10.65 shipping
+J7 ^ X&* T] w. XR? N!|E/ $
LOT OF 7 AMERICANA 750 pc puzzles CATS / DOG DAYS / SHOPKEEPERS & MORE COMPLETE
$31.99
or Best Offer
$10.99 shipping
+^CJ & *T ]6 w.O?E FN !|/ A$
NFL SHOWDOWN Board Game Football You Call The Plays Buffalo Games - NEW/SEALED
(3)
$25.00
$8.23 shipping
+^ &H* ]B w. ?!|/Y 7 $BP
❤️LOT OF 3 FAIRY PUZZLES. NIB. JODY BERGSMA, SHEILA WOLK, & JOSEPHINE WALL
$48.99
or Best Offer
$15.25 shipping
+F^S &* M ] w3.?! |S/S VA L $
Lot Of 3 Cat Puzzles Buffalo 750 Pcs Complete Posters Included
$15.99
$13.00 shipping
IX+ ^ &KZ Q*R ] w .?M!|/ $E
6 Puzzle Lot BUFFALO GAMES Amazing Nature JOSIE LEWIS Days to Remember SOME NEW!
$34.95
$17.05 shipping
+^X 5 O&*S NR W] Rw D.J?!|/ $
LOST IN A JIGSAW The Diagonal Maze Puzzle by Buffalo Games Inc. NEW SEALED 1997
(5)
$19.99
or Best Offer
$8.65 shipping
E+6^ &* IV Q]6 w.?!|Q/ $
Worlds Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Cats Edition Buffalo Games VTG 1991 NOS 526
$25.00
or Best Offer
$8.99 shipping
+^H O&* I]K w.?!|9Z/ L$L
Mystery 3D Jigsaw Puzzle HOTEL WHODUNIT Vintage 1993 504 Pcs Buffalo Games New
(1)
$28.00
or Best Offer
$7.95 shipping
+UM^ H L&* 1L] Yw.K ?V!9|/ $
Rare Vtg. 1991 Sealed LAS VEGAS Character Jigsaw Puzzle by Buffalo Games
$75.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
V+^ &F * QD] w T.?!6 1|/ $6 S p o n s o r e d
Buffalo Games Disney USPS Postage Stamps 500 Piece Puzzle NEW SEALED 2004
$33.99
Was: $39.99was - US $39.99
$6.34 shipping
+WB^ H&W* ] ST w.G?D!|/ O$S p o n s o r e d
THE TALKING JIGSAW PUZZLE The Hospital SEALED 2-Sided 560 Pieces 1993 NEW
$135.00
Was: $300.00was - US $300.00
or Best Offer
$10.00 shipping
N+^C &* A ] w.I? S!4 |DH/ $S p o n s o r e d
RARE Buffalo Games Disney USPS Postage Stamps 500 Piece Puzzle - Complete
$12.00
Was: $20.00was - US $20.00
or Best Offer
$6.50 shipping
+^R I &2*R ] 16 w.?3!I|/ $
VTG The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle The Fitness Center 1991 Buffalo Games Sealed READ
(1)
$134.99
Was: $179.99was - US $179.99
$14.40 shipping
N+^O 5 &9* P ]X w.U?T!|/ $
Rare Vintage New Sealed Seattle Washington 513 pieces Buffalo Jigsaw Puzzle
$39.00
$7.85 shipping
JB+^ &* ] w.?!B|2 KH/ S $R
Lot of 1 4 Jigsaw Puzzles Buffalo, Wysocki, Kinkade, Cobble Hill 500, 750, 1000
$72.00
or Best Offer
$24.48 shipping
1+^X &* ] w.?!|/ $EJ D4
Talking Jigsaw Puzzle OFFICE BUILDING 21x15 MISSING ONE PIECE Buffalo Games 1991
(5)
$13.00
$8.85 shipping
+PI^ &DV* ] w. YN ?!|/14 8$
The Office Building - Talking Jigsaw Puzzle Two Sided 560 Pieces New Sealed RARE
(5)
$55.00
or Best Offer
$13.17 shipping
+^C &X * K] 7w.? Z9!|/ 8$B
NEW The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle "The Beach" 1992 Buffalo Games
(4)
$109.99
or Best Offer
$12.30 shipping
GW+ ^ &* ]W N wN.?!4| U/4 $
VINTAGE BUFFALO GAMES PUZZLE “CITY OF LAS VEGAS” 513 PIECES COMPLETE
$8.00
$7.16 shipping
0 bids
11h 57m
+P^U &D* ] U wH.?Y! U|0 6T/ $
Lot Of 4 Buffalo Games And Puzzles Jigsaw Puzzles
$0.99
$7.21 shipping
1 bid
5d 16h
+ET^ &* ] w.1Y?!|/ W$0
THE GRINCH MERRY GRINCHMAS 500 PIECE Holiday Magic LIGHT UP PUZZLE 2024 RARE new
$39.00
or Best Offer
$9.39 shipping
0 bids
1d 17h
8+^ 5&* V]R w.?I!|/ $4 PT
Lot 6 Complete 750 Pc Puzzles Shopkeepers Back To The Past Series candy toy pets
$38.00
$13.85 shipping
+^S3 PG &A2 *BM ] w.JD ?!|/ $
500 Piece Puzzle Amazing Nature Rare Birds Pre-owned Complete Poster Included
$0.99
or Best Offer
$10.12 shipping
0 bids
6d
5+^6 D &W * E] w.?!|/2 T $P
Vintage 1988 Buffalo Games CITY OF HOUSTON ASTROWORLD PUZZLE Complete 504 pcs
$26.99
Was: $29.99was - US $29.99
or Best Offer
$9.58 shipping
+3^ 1 &GV* ]G K w.?4V! |/2 $S p o n s o r e d
PUZZLE 750 Pieces CATS Lesley Anne Ivory Gemma On Patchwork Buffalo Games RARE
$13.99
Was: $19.99was - US $19.99
or Best Offer
$12.40 shipping
11 watching
+7^ &*H ] w. ?!G9 |V7/ $ 43S p o n s o r e d
The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle Of All Time 1989 First Episode 512 Pieces Vintage NEW
$22.00
$7.90 shipping
+X^Q Z4 &* ] wK.?6! |Y/ W $S p o n s o r e d
VTG Chippendales Dancers Two Sided Jigsaw Puzzle 500 Pieces SEALED NOS🔥
$39.95
or Best Offer
$9.49 shipping
+^ &* R] w.?V XE !|/ $AQ DS p o n s o r e d
🧩 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzles Lot of 2 Bear Hug Koalas Spring Buffalo Games
$12.12
or Best Offer
$8.32 shipping
I+E^ &* ] w.EI? D!B A|D/ $
- Country Life - Antique Barn - 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
(4)
$15.85
Free shipping
7 watching
+^ U&3* ] 9 A 1Iw .?!8|A / F$
Buffalo Pokemon Pikachu Character 500 Pc Puzzle New Sealed Damaged Box READ
(1)
$7.77
Was: $12.95was - US $12.95
or Best Offer
$6.84 shipping
+13^ & A8* ] wU.?!M |K/ W $
Lot of 8 Jigsaw Puzzles Buffalo, Aimee Stewart, Advent, Beer, Lake 500p 1000p
$13.99
or Best Offer
$23.00 shipping
0 bids
5d 18h
+1^ &2* D ] wM. ?!3X|/ $ Z
Notre Dame Fighting Irish Jigsaw Puzzle New Sealed 513 pieces 1996 John Holladay
(2)
$49.99
or Best Offer
$2.99 shipping
+^N &I* PU] w.E?!E HW |5/Y $
The Hospital, VTG Talking Jigsaw Puzzle, Buffalo Games, 560 pieces 1993 complete
$75.00
or Best Offer
$13.10 shipping
0 bids
7h 44m
+^AZ &*9K ] w P.2? R!Z |/3V $
NEW Talking Jigsaw Puzzle The Fitness Center 560 Pieces Two Sided 1991 Buffalo
$118.00
or Best Offer
$12.58 shipping
L+^ &0* ] Ww6. GI N?!Y|/ PS $S p o n s o r e d
Vintage 1984 Buffalo Games City Of Pittsburgh 504+ Piece Puzzle Complete
$18.00
or Best Offer
$6.34 shipping
+^LJ CO &* ] Qw.Y?! |BW/ $S p o n s o r e d
🏈🔴🟡Vintage, NFL Kansas City Chiefs 1994 RARE 513 Piece Puzzle Collectible🔴🟡
$37.00
or Best Offer
$10.65 shipping
31 C+^H &* 5 O] HT 1wF.?!|/ $
NEW Talking Jigsaw Puzzle The Fitness Center 560 Pieces Two Sided 1991 Buffalo
(1)
$105.00
or Best Offer
$7.16 shipping
+T^ 3 V&5 M* D] w.?9!|/L R $
Vtg 1994 Cleveland Browns Jigsaw Puzzle SEALED Box NFL Football 513 Pcs.
$0.99
$7.99 shipping
0 bids
3d
2+^ &*Z HL QI ] w.?XN!| 6L / $
VTG Panoramic Jigsaw Puzzle NEW YORK CITY Glow in the Dark 750pc 3' Twin Towers
(2)
$19.95
or Best Offer
$11.70 shipping
PA +P2 CU^ Q&3* ] w0.6?!| / $
Buffalo Games Antique Barn 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle
(4)
$19.54
$5.99 shipping
+IE ^ O&*U ] w A.Y ?!|FQ /C $
NFL ShowDown 19 Playbook Cards Replacement Pieces Parts
(3)
$8.25
Free shipping
EN+^ &* 4] w.S ?!|T8 / CT V$
VTG City of Baltimore Puzzle 529 Piece 1990 Buffalo Games Inc, NEW SEALED
$34.99
Free shipping
+^ &X7* ] w.? !WA|/ ZB$ Y9
1993 The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle THE HOSPITAL Two Sided 560 Piece Buffalo Complete
(2)
$74.99
Free shipping
FF UU+^ WU&* ] OwV. ?G!|/ $
THE TALKING JIGSAW PUZZLE! - 1993 THE HIGH SCHOOL - 560 pcs 2 Sided Sealed NIB
(2)
$105.00
or Best Offer
$13.00 shipping
EJ+^ &*A 5 8N] w Z.5? !|/ $
The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle "The Fitness Center" Buffalo Games 1992 *Complete*
(1)
$75.99
$6.53 shipping
+^8 &* ] J wY.?9 !FH| NF O/1 $
Vtg CITY OF DETROIT Jigsaw Puzzle Buffalo Games 504 Pieces 1988 COMPLETE
$15.99
or Best Offer
$6.45 shipping
H+U^ &1* 7] Rw.?3!| CY/ $
World's Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Double Sided Jungle Edition Vintage USA New
$18.95
$6.51 shipping
+IT^ &2* N] YwX .?!|H/ I$
Vintage Sealed Packers "Go Green Bay!" Jigsaw Puzzle Art by John Holladay NFL
$18.95
$6.65 shipping
+^69 & D* 2] S4 Lw.?M!|/ $
RARE NEW WORLD’S MOST DIFFICULT JIGSAW PUZZLE TENNIS EDITION COLLECTORS SALE
$50.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
0+Z ZI^ R&1 P* ] wP.?! 9|/ $
VTG 1987 World's Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Leprechauns 500 pc New 15 x 15"
(2)
$14.99
or Best Offer
$6.34 shipping
V+^ I &26* ] wB.?!|Q/ 99 K$
Vintage Fort Lauderdale - Miami - Florida 1988 504 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Complete
$14.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
5P +^ L&* 6 ]Y4 1 w.T ?5!|Y / $
Lost in a Jigsaw Diagonal Maze Puzzle Escape From Eden Buffalo Games 1997 - New!
(5)
$15.16
Was: $18.95was - US $18.95
or Best Offer
$6.99 shipping
+T7 DY ^JP &* ]EW w.?EO!| / $
The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle of All Time First Episode Buffalo Games Sealed 1989
$13.45
Was: $14.95was - US $14.95
$11.40 shipping
WY +^ &* ] KOw TV. H?!|/V GO $
VTG 1988 City of Boston Jigsaw Puzzle -COMPLETE, 504 Triple-Thick Pcs., Preowned
$9.99
or Best Offer
$10.65 shipping
Q+B ^ &4* ]V 77 Pw.?!G G|J/ $S p o n s o r e d
Vintage 1991 Sealed LAS VEGAS Character Jigsaw Puzzle by Buffalo Games Rare
$59.95
$9.95 shipping
+^ &Z* ]W wM1.? !|/ $EZ G2 S p o n s o r e d

Best Selling

See All

The Fitness Center Talking 2 Sided Jigsaw Puzzle 560 PC 1992 Don Scott Complete
(1)
$134.99 New
$75.99 Used
Beach Holiday 2000 Piece Puzzle by Buffalo Games & Puzzles
(1)
$14.00 New
Buffalo Games 2306 Pokemon Frames Puzzle - 2000 Piece
(7)
$35.00 New
$19.50 Used
First Episode The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle of All Time 1989 Buffalo Games 2 Sided
$10.88 New
Buffalo Games Pokemon Eevee's Stained Glass Jigsaw Puzzle - 02300
(9)
$9.28 New
Buffalo Games Star Wars Puzzle Rebellions Are Built on Hope 2000 Pcs #2064
(6)
$44.47 New
$26.99 Used
Buffalo Games 2103 Star Wars Quest Inside: Battle of Hoth Jigsaw Puzzle - 2000 Piece
(11)
$38.00 New
$27.00 Used
Devils Dilemma The Worlds Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle 500 PC 1985 Tuco
(2)
$44.99 New
$15.00 Used

Top Rated

See All

Buffalo Games 2306 Pokemon Frames Puzzle - 2000 Piece
(7)

100% agree - Durable
$35.00 New
$19.50 Used
Buffalo Games 2103 Star Wars Quest Inside: Battle of Hoth Jigsaw Puzzle - 2000 Piece
(11)

100% agree - Would recommend
$38.00 New
$27.00 Used
Buffalo Games Pokemon Eevee's Stained Glass Jigsaw Puzzle - 02300
(9)

88% agree - Durable
$9.28 New

Theme

Number of Pieces

Motors

Clothing & Accessories

Sporting goods

Electronics

Business & Industrial

Jewelry & Watches

Collectibles & Art

Home & garden

Other categories

Buffalo Games Collectors & Hobbyists Puzzles

Shop by Category

1,444 Results

LOT OF 4 - RAVENSBURGER - 500 PC PIECES - PREMIUM JIGSAW PUZZLES - NEW & USED

LOT / 9 - BUFFALO PUZZLES - 300 / 500 / 750 PC PIECES - ANIMALS - CASTLES - DOGS

Houston Astroworld Jigsaw Puzzle BUFFALO GAMES Vtg 1988 City Character Puzzle

Devil’s Dilemma World's Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Buffalo Games 1987 Complete

Vintage 1989 The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle Of All Time Two Sided 512pcs New

LOT OF 7 AMERICANA 750 pc puzzles CATS / DOG DAYS / SHOPKEEPERS & MORE COMPLETE

NFL SHOWDOWN Board Game Football You Call The Plays Buffalo Games - NEW/SEALED

❤️LOT OF 3 FAIRY PUZZLES. NIB. JODY BERGSMA, SHEILA WOLK, & JOSEPHINE WALL

Lot Of 3 Cat Puzzles Buffalo 750 Pcs Complete Posters Included

6 Puzzle Lot BUFFALO GAMES Amazing Nature JOSIE LEWIS Days to Remember SOME NEW!

LOST IN A JIGSAW The Diagonal Maze Puzzle by Buffalo Games Inc. NEW SEALED 1997

Worlds Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Cats Edition Buffalo Games VTG 1991 NOS 526

Mystery 3D Jigsaw Puzzle HOTEL WHODUNIT Vintage 1993 504 Pcs Buffalo Games New

Rare Vtg. 1991 Sealed LAS VEGAS Character Jigsaw Puzzle by Buffalo Games

Buffalo Games Disney USPS Postage Stamps 500 Piece Puzzle NEW SEALED 2004

THE TALKING JIGSAW PUZZLE The Hospital SEALED 2-Sided 560 Pieces 1993 NEW

RARE Buffalo Games Disney USPS Postage Stamps 500 Piece Puzzle - Complete

VTG The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle The Fitness Center 1991 Buffalo Games Sealed READ

Rare Vintage New Sealed Seattle Washington 513 pieces Buffalo Jigsaw Puzzle

Lot of 1 4 Jigsaw Puzzles Buffalo, Wysocki, Kinkade, Cobble Hill 500, 750, 1000

Talking Jigsaw Puzzle OFFICE BUILDING 21x15 MISSING ONE PIECE Buffalo Games 1991

The Office Building - Talking Jigsaw Puzzle Two Sided 560 Pieces New Sealed RARE

NEW The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle "The Beach" 1992 Buffalo Games

VINTAGE BUFFALO GAMES PUZZLE “CITY OF LAS VEGAS” 513 PIECES COMPLETE

Lot Of 4 Buffalo Games And Puzzles Jigsaw Puzzles

THE GRINCH MERRY GRINCHMAS 500 PIECE Holiday Magic LIGHT UP PUZZLE 2024 RARE new

Lot 6 Complete 750 Pc Puzzles Shopkeepers Back To The Past Series candy toy pets

500 Piece Puzzle Amazing Nature Rare Birds Pre-owned Complete Poster Included

Vintage 1988 Buffalo Games CITY OF HOUSTON ASTROWORLD PUZZLE Complete 504 pcs

PUZZLE 750 Pieces CATS Lesley Anne Ivory Gemma On Patchwork Buffalo Games RARE

The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle Of All Time 1989 First Episode 512 Pieces Vintage NEW

VTG Chippendales Dancers Two Sided Jigsaw Puzzle 500 Pieces SEALED NOS🔥

🧩 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzles Lot of 2 Bear Hug Koalas Spring Buffalo Games

- Country Life - Antique Barn - 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle

Buffalo Pokemon Pikachu Character 500 Pc Puzzle New Sealed Damaged Box READ

Lot of 8 Jigsaw Puzzles Buffalo, Aimee Stewart, Advent, Beer, Lake 500p 1000p

Notre Dame Fighting Irish Jigsaw Puzzle New Sealed 513 pieces 1996 John Holladay

The Hospital, VTG Talking Jigsaw Puzzle, Buffalo Games, 560 pieces 1993 complete

NEW Talking Jigsaw Puzzle The Fitness Center 560 Pieces Two Sided 1991 Buffalo

Vintage 1984 Buffalo Games City Of Pittsburgh 504+ Piece Puzzle Complete

🏈🔴🟡Vintage, NFL Kansas City Chiefs 1994 RARE 513 Piece Puzzle Collectible🔴🟡

NEW Talking Jigsaw Puzzle The Fitness Center 560 Pieces Two Sided 1991 Buffalo

Vtg 1994 Cleveland Browns Jigsaw Puzzle SEALED Box NFL Football 513 Pcs.

VTG Panoramic Jigsaw Puzzle NEW YORK CITY Glow in the Dark 750pc 3' Twin Towers

Buffalo Games Antique Barn 500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle

NFL ShowDown 19 Playbook Cards Replacement Pieces Parts

VTG City of Baltimore Puzzle 529 Piece 1990 Buffalo Games Inc, NEW SEALED

1993 The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle THE HOSPITAL Two Sided 560 Piece Buffalo Complete

THE TALKING JIGSAW PUZZLE! - 1993 THE HIGH SCHOOL - 560 pcs 2 Sided Sealed NIB

The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle "The Fitness Center" Buffalo Games 1992 *Complete*

Vtg CITY OF DETROIT Jigsaw Puzzle Buffalo Games 504 Pieces 1988 COMPLETE

World's Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Double Sided Jungle Edition Vintage USA New

Vintage Sealed Packers "Go Green Bay!" Jigsaw Puzzle Art by John Holladay NFL

RARE NEW WORLD’S MOST DIFFICULT JIGSAW PUZZLE TENNIS EDITION COLLECTORS SALE

VTG 1987 World's Most Difficult Jigsaw Puzzle Leprechauns 500 pc New 15 x 15"

Vintage Fort Lauderdale - Miami - Florida 1988 504 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Complete

Lost in a Jigsaw Diagonal Maze Puzzle Escape From Eden Buffalo Games 1997 - New!

The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle of All Time First Episode Buffalo Games Sealed 1989

VTG 1988 City of Boston Jigsaw Puzzle -COMPLETE, 504 Triple-Thick Pcs., Preowned

Vintage 1991 Sealed LAS VEGAS Character Jigsaw Puzzle by Buffalo Games Rare

Best Selling

The Fitness Center Talking 2 Sided Jigsaw Puzzle 560 PC 1992 Don Scott Complete

Beach Holiday 2000 Piece Puzzle by Buffalo Games & Puzzles

Buffalo Games 2306 Pokemon Frames Puzzle - 2000 Piece

First Episode The Greatest Jigsaw Puzzle of All Time 1989 Buffalo Games 2 Sided

Buffalo Games Pokemon Eevee's Stained Glass Jigsaw Puzzle - 02300

Buffalo Games Star Wars Puzzle Rebellions Are Built on Hope 2000 Pcs #2064

Buffalo Games 2103 Star Wars Quest Inside: Battle of Hoth Jigsaw Puzzle - 2000 Piece

The Talking Jigsaw Puzzle "The Fitness Center" Buffalo Games 1992 Complete